Right up there with Blazing Saddles and Cat Ballou.
Released in 1945. Produced by Gary Cooper.
Written by Nunnally Johnson and Alan LeMay. Nunnally Johnson wrote many of the fine films of the time. Alan LeMay wrote the best western film ever made, and our favorite of all time: The Searchers.
This one magnificently acted by Gary Cooper. He plays a cowboy whose name, for real, is Melody Jones. A cowboy named Melody?
The plot is that there is a stage holdup, and one of the outlaws gets shot.
Ok so far. But then Gary Cooper and his sidekick ride into town, and the problem is that they both look like the stagecoach robbers.
Mixups after mixups.
But Melody Jones is not only not a stagecoach robber, but he is also the most incompetent cowboy in film history. He can't do anything. When he draws his gun it goes flying across the room. He ends up in a shootout with the real robber, and he can't hit the broad side of a barn. In fact, his new love has to shoot the outlaw for him....but he's so incompetent he thinks she was trying to shoot him but missed and accidentally hit the outlaw.
He can't fight, he can barely ride. He struts into a saloon thinking he's hot stuff (a scene that's side-splitting) and everybody gives way to him........but what he doesn't know is that they all think he's the stagecoach robber.
Scene after scene after scene like this.
Gary Cooper shows a side of his acting ability that we haven't seen in any of his other films.
A film lost to time, except to those few of us who love old westerns.